“And Who Are You?”
In Italy, the first question you will get asked at a party is, “How old are you?” It’s not considered a rude question at all. It’s not equivalent to asking a woman’s dress size, how much money is in your bank account, or if you get regular plastic surgery. In fact, the question gets asked with such a bright-eyed sincerity of interest that you can’t help but answer, as if the answer is nothing to you. If you’re under 35, the answer most likely is nothing to you.
Of course, the first question people ask you in America is, “What do you do?”
We don’t know how to interact with a stranger until we know this answer. And I’d venture to say that we don’t often ask it with a sincerity of interest. We ask it with a tad bit of statusing (it’s no wonder that Facebook, an American invention, would have “status updates”).
I think one of the hardest things to be in this country is a person without a job. Should you ever be out with people who do actually go to an office, a cubicle, a workplace on a daily basis, and another person comes up to you, it’s tough to be without the answer to “What do you do?”
You could try and steer the conversation in another direction: “I don’t think that waiter should be on fire, do you?”
Or you could try and dig into some depth by sharing a piece of yourself with that person. You could say, “I’m taking some time off to figure out what I really want to be doing with my life. Find those things that fulfill me. Inspire me. Feed my soul.” (The person listening to this will respond with one of three things: 1. “Wow, you’re really brave.” 2. “I wish I could do that.” 3. “Is that waiter on fire?”)
In America, we think that the answer to what we do defines who we are. It’s our commodity. It’s the thing we can sell to other people to buy their interest in us, or to fill up that sense that we have success because we have status. (How very American of us to add a level of capitalism to our personal lives like this.) Ask any retiree, or any stay-at-home mom what kinds of interest they generate from others when they answer what they do all day and you’ll see what I mean about how our jobs define us, and how not having a job relegates us to being as interesting to others as micro-economics classes are to art students.
In Italy, one of the rudest questions you can ask someone is, “What do you do?” An Italian will look at you hurt and surprised that such a thing would even come out of your mouth so smoothly like that. Didn’t your mother teach you any manners? “Why do you want to know?” they’ll ask before the once delightful and pleasant conversation comes to a dead stop.
It’s as if the question doesn’t really attempt to get at the heart of anyone.






